Showing posts with label Dream Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dream Act. Show all posts

Sunday, November 11, 2012

There is Light at the End of the Tunnel for the Immigration Reform/DREAM Act!


             The re-election of President Barack Obama in this 2012 election might indicate     a bright future for immigration reform as well as for the Dream Act. A few days after the president's re-election, a tangible impact on the issue of immigration has already been felt: Maryland State has passed a version of Dream Act, and at the same time Democrat and Republican senators gave an interview to NBC’s “Meet the Press” to recall reviewing the opposition of Republicans on the immigration reform.
               In Annapolis, State of Maryland provided its own version of Dream Act which was actually passed with the 58 percent of votes in the referendum.  So, as of today, this is the 13th state, which can be as an example for other states to “allow illegal immigrant to pay in-state tuition at public colleges, if they meet certain qualifications.” Frank Sharry, executive director of America’s Voice Education fund has said:” … winning a statewide referendum for the first time often has a way of showing that has passed through the “crucible of American politics” and officially arrived as an issue. She thinks that “this is a huge turning point in the nationwide debate about immigration policy, and it should be seen in that light.” This is the real hope for undocumented immigrants in the State of Maryland. Passing this act could be their biggest chance to go on and improve their lives, and actually to be less dependent on public benefits. By allowing undocumented immigrants to complete diploma in high school and continue their education the college level, they will be converted to law abiding citizens. Also, it was written in a new report from the Maryland Institute for Policy Analysis and Research at the University of Maryland (MIPAR), Baltimore County, that the Maryland Dream Act will benefit the State financially and economically by adding approximately $66 million annually to the State’s budget.  “Even if the only consideration is the fiscal effects on state and local governments, the net economic effects of the Maryland Dream Act will be positive.” Also, as studies have shown 435 high school students are willing and, actually, it is the one of Dream Act’s terms, to continue their education in colleges in Maryland. “The family would need to decide at least three years before high school graduation to move to Maryland, and once in the state would need to make sure that the student spent a minimum of three years in, and graduate from, a Maryland high school (as well as paying state and federal income taxes for all years).” So approving the Dream Act will benefit illegal immigrants and the economic condition of the state.
             Democrat Senator Charles Schumer has said that he and Republican Senator Lindsey Graham are going officially to recall reviewing the opposition on immigrant reform, which had failed two years ago. “Senator Graham and I are talking to our colleagues about this right now. I think we have a darned good chance using this blueprint to get something done this year. The Republican Party has learned that being…anti-immigrant doesn't work for them politically. And they know it,” Senator Schumer said. This point became clear after seeing the results in this 2012 election and how supporting immigration reform helped bring victory to the democratic party. Barack Obama won 70 percent of Latino’s votes. It was estimated that 12 million illegal immigrants currently live in the United States. According to these numbers something simply has to be done about current immigration situation in the country. And Senator Schumer introduced their comprehensive plan of immigration reform. The plan is consisting of four terms: “requiring high-tech, fraud-proof Social Security cards to ensure that illegal workers cannot get jobs; strengthening border security and enforcement of immigration laws; creating a process for admitting temporary workers; and implementing a path to legal status for immigrants already in the country.” This cooperative plan seems very specific and straight to the point and the best part about this plan that it had been developed by Democrats and Republican in a joint effort, which may eventually lead to success
          After analyzing the post-election developments on immigration and the Dream Act we can say with certainty that Maryland will now serve as an example for other states on how to educate and legalize undocumented immigrants. Also it is safe to say that since the election the roulette has started to roll, and that immigration issues are being properly addressed now. Also with both parties, Democrats and Republicans,  working together there is greater hope to resolve these problems.

Thursday, November 8, 2012

Second Chance for Obama



       President Obama won reelection on November 6th 2012.  Obama's administration kept deporting people categorizing them as "criminals", but promises residency to students. What will happen next?
Click to read: After the election: Immigration

Thursday, October 25, 2012

Not Much for the Dreamers




          Immigration reform is quite a sensitive issue for numerous voters in this upcoming election, especially Latino voters. Many people who hoped for this issue to be discussed were quite disappointed to find that the issue was left unmentioned in the first debate. Although it was discussed quite briefly—five minutes—in the second debate, nothing new was presented. President Barack Obama and Governor Mitt Romney were both asked about their immigration plans. The two candidates presented their views and plans on immigration reform. From their discussion, it seems that there is very little hope for the supporters of the DREAM Act, an immigration reform bill that would provide more opportunities for undocumented aliens.
          Republican candidate Romney had always been against the DREAM Act. During the second debate, he said he opposes any amnesty for those without valid documents in America. Romney supports “self-deportation” and he is strongly against providing jobs to illegal immigrants. He also said he opposes driver's licenses and same state college tuition fees for undocumented aliens. The only pathway is “military service” to become a permanent resident of the United States for young people. But the fact is the military does not allow illegal immigrants to enlist. He opposes legalization for the "illegal" and forbids any benefits for them. Overall, he would make their lives miserable so that undocumented residents would be forced to leave.
       President Obama expressed his sympathy and support for those people who risked their lives to come here just to take care of their families. He is not willing to deport those groups of people who were bought by their families and think this is their country. He also stated that being an immigrant and being a criminal are two different things. People who came here to support their family are not criminals. He also mentioned that the Obama administration has worked diligently to pass the act. However, when asked why he did not present this bill to Congress in his first two years when his party was a majority in Congress, he could not provide a satisfactory answer. Obama has been criticized for not trying hard to pass this act in his term as he promised. On June 15, 2012, Obama announced that America will stop the deportation of eligible people under the DREAM Act and provide a two-year work permit for them. However, this may only be a trick to garner some votes, as suspected by some. Although many are hopeful of President Obama's stance on immigration reform, the fact remains that his actions have been different from his campaign promises. A few websites such as CBS news, Washington post, PBS news, ABC news and many others reported that America had the largest number (about 1.2 million over three years) of deportation during Obama’s term. Clearly, immigration was not a priority for him.
           In conclusion, taking into account the positions of both candidates and their respective consequences, seems to present the following dilemma: If Romney wins, he will not pass DREAM Act and probably follow the model of Arizona to encourage self-deportation. If Obama wins, he will not do much without the support of the Republicans. Both Romney and Obama admitted that we don’t have enough resources to deport 11.2 million people (by Pew Hispanic Center report, 2011). Regardless of whoever wins, it can be concluded from both candidate’s words and actions that there is not much hope on immigration reform or to pass DREAM Act in the coming future.

Published by Shanjida Khatun
 Updated on 11/1/12

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

[Updated] Impacts of the DREAM Act



Growing up in the United States of America might sound a great deal for many immigrant young people. America is a symbol of good life and a promising successful future. For the immigrant youths, the legislation of the DREAM Act will grant them a better and equal footing in the American society. Electoral candidates have expressed their positions about the DREAM Act and all of them believe that their stance will create better outcomes for everyone. The impacts of the DREAM Act can either be a step forward or a step backward not just for the immigrant youths, but for all the American people once it is finally realized by the incoming leaders of the country.  
Immigration law has an extensive history of debate in the United States. In the past, administration leaders and a greater portion of the American citizenry have always been in objection to the growing number of immigrants in the country. In 2001, the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act or DREAM Act commenced in the House through the proposal bill of Republican Senator Orrin Hatch, Democratic Senator Richard Durbin, Representative Howard Berman of California and Representative Chris Cannon of Utah. (Immigration Policy Center; Ojeda 2) According to this bill, undocumented or illegal immigrants who arrived to the country before they were sixteen years old will be permitted for conditional permanent residency if they qualify with the prerequisites. (Immigration Policy Center; Ojeda 2) The bill faced many challenges and criticism, including its passing in the Senate. Some of its first supporters also dropped their endorsement for the bill. When President Barack Obama ran for the position, he earned the trust and confidence of many immigrants after he supported the DREAM Act. He also promised to improve the immigration laws so as it would not be too rigorous on immigrants. However, the DREAM Act failed approval in the Senate, but its proponents, including President Obama, continued to push for its legislation. At present, the DREAM Act is a hope for many young immigrants treated as illegal in the country they call home while it is seen as a threat to some of the legal residents of the United States.
The DREAM Act is supposed to encourage the future of more than two million children and teens that were brought by their parents before they reach the age of sixteen or already born in the US from migrant parents (Immigration Policy Center; Ojeda 2; Costantini; Aguilar). These marginalized youths have suffered in the past, where most of them were no longer allowed to continue attending school, not allowed to enter jobs, or worse, their parents got arrested and can no longer provide for their needs. With the DREAM Act, they are promised a better future with a new status and with equal recognition to legitimate American residents.
There are several positive and negative impacts of the proposed bill, if one will look at the two sides of the coin. For the advantages, its proponents specified a number of positive outcomes of the bill, mostly of economic significance. Many young immigrants will get their education and better paying careers. This would mean that their earnings in the future will contribute to the nation’s income. Studies from Arizona State University in 2008 and UCLA North American Integration and Development Center in 2012 showed that immigrants will greatly generate hundreds of thousands to millions from their future professions. (Immigration Policy Center) According to the Center for American Progress and Partnership for a New American Economy, about $329 billion will be expected by 2030 (Costantini; Aguilar; Guzmán and Jara). Aside from future financial gains on taxes and consumer spending, legalizing these young immigrants will help harness a new breed of professionals, skilled workers, talented individuals and business magnates (Immigration Policy Center; Guzmán and Jara) which will further strengthen the human resources of the nation. They will be able to enter colleges and universities instead of dropping out of school, which will also mean that they will be paying their tuition fees (Immigration Policy Center). With these young immigrants achieving a legal status in the future, a stable recruitment base for the military forces will be sustained, helping ensure the nation’s security and safety. About eight percent of military recruits are immigrants (Immigration Policy Center), which means it will increase further if these young people will be granted the legal status.
However, there is also the downside for the DREAM Act. According Representative Lamar Smith of Texas, the bill is sort of a ‘mass amnesty’ and a ‘magnet for fraud. (Clark) Steven Camarota of the Center for Immigration Studies noted that “funds and slots are limited at state universities and community colleges” (Camarota) which will result to crowding out of legal citizens and additional taxes for tax payers (Clark).     
With the presidential election roughly a month to go, President Obama already accepted his failure to make immigration reforms possible and the DREAM Act to become a law. He also pointed the fingers to the Republicans for the failure of the DREAM Act. While President Obama implemented Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, Senator Romney who strongly opposed the DREAM Act previously, being a Republican, had recent statements that he will contemplate on the bill if these illegal immigrants will enter military service. Obviously, the presidential candidates are wooing the immigrants who are part of the voting population. I believe that the issue of legalizing these young immigrants is a great step forward for the whole American society. Whether it’s the DREAM Act or another bill to be legislated by the next leaders of the country, there will always be likeable and unfavorable impacts, depending on whose side one goes with. It might be better to remind all of them that America is the land of the free, and where equality and justice were once fought for by the precious life of our ancestors and leaders. 

Friday, October 5, 2012


DREAM Act Will Create 1.4 million New Jobs and $329 billion to the U.S. Economy



   On October 1, The Washington Post posted a report from The Center of American Progress. The result of this report may provide a path to pass The DREAM Act. The reports states that The DREAM Act can impact an estimated 2.1 million youths. As a result, would add $329 billion and 1.4 million new jobs to the U.S. economy by 2030 based on the data from the American Community Survey .

According to the report:

   We concluded from this report that enabling 2.1 million eager-to-be-Americans, to achieve the American dream, would boost our economy significantly. First, enacting the law would provide an incentive for such individuals to pursue higher education because for most of those who would be eligible for the legalization provisions can only be attained through completion of high school and some college. Achieving a higher education opens the door to higher-paying jobs, enabling these undocumented youths to become much more productive members of our society. Second, gaining legal status itself translates into higher earnings for these youth; since legal status allows DREAMers to apply to a broader range of high-paying jobs rather than having to resort to low-wage jobs from employers who are willing to pay them off the books.

How it works:






Friday, September 28, 2012

Pros and Cons of the DREAM Act



     There are many debates surrounding the Dream Act  issue and here are the two of the more popularly held views: 

CONS:
1.     High enough unemployment rate will raise even more: The Dream Act will be funded on the backs of hard working, law-abiding Americans -- CBO failed to assess costs for education, increased levels of unemployment due to the addition of workers to the workforce, and increases in potential applicants because of loopholes.
2.     It will overwhelm our street with criminals: The Dream Act provides safe harbor for any alien, including criminals, from being removed or deported if they simply submit an application - burden of proving inaccurate information on a Dream Act application is on the Department of Homeland Security. Certain inadmissible aliens, including those from high-risk regions, will be eligible for amnesty under the Dream Act.
3.     Conservative estimates suggest that at least 1.3 million illegal aliens will be eligible for the Dream Act amnesty. In reality, we have no idea how many illegal aliens will apply.
4.     It won't make us more educated: The Dream Act does not require that an illegal alien finish any type of degree (vocational, two-year, or bachelor’s degree) as a condition of amnesty - the applicant only has to complete the equivalent of two years of college.
5.     It will harm our economy: Current illegal aliens will get federal student loans, federal work study programs, and other forms of Federal Financial Aid. Who will pay for all those benefits?


PROS:
1.     It Will Help Our Economy: According to a recent UCLA study, students that would be impacted by the Dream Act could add between $1.4 to $3.6 trillion in taxable income to our economy over the course of careers, depending on how many ultimately gain legal status. According to the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office, the Dream Act in its current form will cut the deficit by $1.4 billion and increase government revenues by $2.3 billion over the next 10 years.
2.     The Dream Act supports our troops: Secretary of Defense Gates has written to Dream Act sponsors citing the rich precedent of non-citizens serving in the U.S. military and stating that “the Dream Act represents an opportunity to expand [the recruiting] pool, to the advantage of military recruiting and readiness".
3.     The Dream Act is a great return on money we have already invested and will prepare the country for the global economy: Today’s global economy requires an educated and skilled workforce capable of acquiring, creating, and distributing knowledge.  Passage of the Dream Act will mean a group of talented, multilingual and multicultural workers will help America compete with innovators throughout the world.   
4.     Passage of the Dream Act will reduce high school dropout rates and enable more students to attend college:  Foreign-born students represent a significant and growing percentage of the current student population.  Unfortunately, immigration status and the associated barriers to higher education contribute to a higher-than-average high dropout rate, which costs taxpayers and the economy billions of dollars each year.  The Dream Act would eliminate these barriers for many students, and the Dream Act’s high school graduation requirement would provide a powerful incentive for students who might otherwise drop out to stay in school and graduate.


Please find sources used on our Bibliography page.